Crypto License in Anjouan

Securing the Crypto License in Anjouan

Anjouan, an autonomous island within the Union of the Comoros, has rapidly emerged as one of the most attractive and cost-effective jurisdictions for businesses operating in the digital asset space. Regulated by the Anjouan Offshore Finance Authority (AOFA), its framework is specifically designed to accommodate Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs), offering a straightforward, fast-track process for obtaining an International Crypto License. This positioning makes Anjouan an essential strategic consideration for FinTech startups, established exchanges, and digital asset firms seeking to legitimize their global operations with a single, versatile permit.

The Anjouan Crypto License grants broad permissions for activities ranging from exchange operation and custody to token issuance, making it a powerful tool for global market entry. Its primary appeal lies in the combination of a tax-free offshore environment and a remarkably fast licensing timeline, often allowing companies to become operational in a matter of weeks. This guide provides an exhaustive, SEO-optimized analysis of the regulatory landscape, detailed requirements, costs, and compliance obligations necessary to secure and maintain VASP authorization in Anjouan.

The Anjouan Regulatory Framework and VASP Scope

The legal basis for the Anjouan International Crypto License is provided by the island’s offshore finance legislation, administered and enforced by the AOFA.

 

Regulatory Authority and Legal Structure

 

The Anjouan Offshore Finance Authority (AOFA) serves as the sole regulator responsible for issuing and supervising licenses for financial activities, including those involving digital assets.

  • Key Regulatory Body: The AOFA oversees the licensing process and ensures compliance with mandatory Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know-Your-Customer (KYC) standards.

  • Legal Entity Requirement: Applicants must first establish an International Business Company (IBC) in Anjouan, which serves as the legal vehicle for the crypto operation. While an Anjouan IBC is preferred for simplicity, registering an IBC in another recognized offshore jurisdiction (like the Seychelles) may also be permissible.

  • Tax Status: Anjouan is a tax-neutral jurisdiction. Licensed IBCs are exempt from corporate income tax, withholding tax, capital gains tax, and VAT on foreign income, offering a significant tax advantage (a high-frequency keyword).

Permitted Activities Under the Crypto License

 

The Anjouan VASP license is highly comprehensive, covering a wide spectrum of digital asset services. This broad scope of authorized activities under a single permit is a major factor driving the jurisdiction’s popularity.

Authorized Crypto ActivityRegulatory Scope Implication
Virtual Asset Exchange OperatorExchange of digital assets for fiat currency or other virtual assets (e.g., operating a crypto-to-fiat exchange).
Custodial Wallet SolutionsProviding services for the custody or administration of virtual assets or the private keys controlling them.
Initial Coin Offerings (ICO)/Token IssuanceEngaging in the mining, offering, or selling of tokens (utility or security tokens, subject to appropriate disclosures).
Financial Derivative OperationsConducting trading operations involving digital assets, such as Contracts for Difference (CFD) or futures.
Liquidity ProvisionOffering liquidity solutions for the trading of cryptocurrencies.

Corporate and Financial Prerequisites for Licensing

The application process is designed to be streamlined, focusing primarily on the integrity of the key personnel and the company’s foundational structure, minimizing the complexity of local operational requirements.

 

Corporate Establishment and Minimal Local Presence

 

Anjouan is an offshore jurisdiction, meaning it imposes minimal physical requirements compared to major onshore financial centers.

  • No Local Staff Requirement: There is no mandatory requirement for local directors, managers, or dedicated local staff. This reduces overhead and simplifies staffing for global operations.

  • Registered Agent: The IBC must appoint a Local Registered Agent authorized by the AOFA to handle official communications and maintenance of the corporate register.

  • Capital Requirements: Anjouan is highly attractive due to its low financial barrier to entry. There are no mandatory minimum share capital requirements specifically for the crypto license, though applicants must demonstrate sufficient financial backing and solvency relative to their projected business scale.

Due Diligence on Key Personnel

 

The AOFA performs a mandatory Fit and Proper Test on all Ultimate Beneficial Owners (UBOs), directors, and compliance officers to ensure probity and professional reputation.

  • Impeccable Business Reputation: All key individuals must demonstrate a clean professional and personal history.

  • Police Clearance: A recent Police Clearance Certificate (or equivalent criminal record check) is required from the country of residency for all UBOs and directors.

  • References: The application must include both a Bank Reference Letter and a Professional Reference Letter (from a lawyer or accountant), confirming a client relationship of typically two or more years.

Key Document Checklist for AOFA Submission

 

The success of the application hinges on the completeness and certification of the required documentation.

Document CategoryRequired SubmissionCertification Requirement
PersonalPassport Copy, Proof of Address (utility bill < 3 months), CV, Police Clearance, SoF Declaration.Notarized and/or Apostilled.
CorporateCertificate of Incorporation, Memorandum & Articles of Association, Register of Shareholders/Directors.Certified true copies by the Registered Agent.
OperationalDetailed Business Plan (concept, market analysis, financial forecast), AML/KYC Policies, Terms & Conditions.Signed and approved by the company’s director(s).
ComplianceAppointment document for the AML Compliance Officer/MLRO.AOFA submission requirement.

The Licensing Process: Timeline, Costs, and Renewal

One of Anjouan’s strongest competitive features is the expedited licensing process, which contrasts sharply with the often multi-month timelines in jurisdictions like Malta or the EU.

 

Cost Structure and Affordability

 

The Crypto License in Anjouan is one of the most affordable options globally, significantly reducing the initial burden on startups. The total cost structure, including low government fees and the absence of GGR taxes, offers substantial long-term savings.

Cost Category (Indicative)Initial Fee (One-off)Annual Fee (Renewal)
Company Formation (IBC)$2,000 – $4,000 USDIncluded in renewal
Government License Fee$5,000 – $10,000 USD$5,000 – $8,000 USD
Key Person/Due Diligence Fee$1,000 – $2,000 USD (per person)$1,000 – $2,000 USD
Total Indicative Cost$8,000 – $16,000+ USD$7,000 – $10,000+ USD

Note: These figures are highly indicative and vary based on the chosen service provider and the complexity of the due diligence required.

 

Typical Licensing Timeline 

 

The streamlined process, facilitated by the AOFA and local agents, allows for exceptionally fast turnaround times.

  1. Phase 1: Company Formation (IBC)

    • Duration: 1-2 weeks (once documentation is complete)

    • Action: Registration of the Anjouan IBC and appointment of a Local Agent.

  2. Phase 2: Application Assembly & Due Diligence

    • Duration: 2-4 weeks

    • Action: Finalizing the Business Plan, drafting the comprehensive AML/KYC Policies, and certifying personal/corporate documents.

  3. Phase 3: Regulator Review & Issuance

    • Duration: 2-3 weeks (AOFA review)

    • Action: Submission to the AOFA; regulatory review and background checks; final License Issuance.

  4. Total Go-Live Time: 6–9 weeks (ideal scenario)

License Renewal

 

The Anjouan Crypto License is valid for one year and must be renewed annually. The renewal process requires an updated set of corporate documents, confirmation of compliance with AML/KYC policies throughout the previous year, and payment of the annual fee.

AML/CFT Compliance: Adhering to International Standards

Despite its offshore status and rapid process, Anjouan requires all licensees to demonstrate a robust commitment to Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Counter-Financing of Terrorism (CFT) protocols, which are increasingly aligned with international standards.

 

The Risk-Based Approach (RBA)

 

The AOFA mandates the adoption of a Risk-Based Approach (RBA), ensuring compliance efforts are proportional to the risks posed by the VASP’s activities and client base.

  • Compliance Officer: The VASP must appoint a Compliance Officer (CO) or Money Laundering Reporting Officer (MLRO). While the officer does not need to be a resident of Anjouan, they must be qualified (ACAMS certification is highly recommended) and be given sufficient authority to oversee compliance.

  • Risk Assessment: The VASP must conduct an initial and ongoing Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing (ML/TF) Risk Assessment tailored to its specific business model, identifying geographical, customer, product, and channel risks.

  • Internal Controls: Comprehensive internal procedures must cover staff training, audit trails, and the management of high-risk scenarios.

KYC and Enhanced Due Diligence (EDD)

 

Strict Know-Your-Customer (KYC) procedures are fundamental to the AOFA’s requirements.

  • Standard CDD: Basic Customer Due Diligence (CDD) for all clients includes identity verification, proof of address, and screening against international sanctions lists (e.g., UN, OFAC).

  • Enhanced Due Diligence (EDD): Required for clients deemed high-risk, such as Politically Exposed Persons (PEPs), clients from high-risk jurisdictions, or those engaging in large-volume or complex, opaque transactions.

  • Transaction Monitoring: Licensees must deploy automatic transaction monitoring systems to detect and flag suspicious activity in real-time. This includes tracking deposits, withdrawals, and trading patterns.

Reporting Obligations

 

VASPs are obligated to report any activity that raises suspicion of money laundering or terrorist financing.

  • Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs): The CO/MLRO must establish a clear protocol for the timely reporting of Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) to the relevant authorities in Anjouan.

  • Record Keeping: All client due diligence records, transaction records, and internal audit trails must be meticulously maintained and securely stored for a minimum period (typically five years).

Technology, Security, and Operational Standards

While the AOFA is relatively light on imposing specific technological architectures, it emphasizes system integrity, security, and the protection of client assets.

 

Cybersecurity and Data Protection

 

  • Technical Description: Applicants must submit a detailed technical description of their platform, including infrastructure, trading engine, and security measures.

  • Data Security: The VASP must implement robust cybersecurity protocols, including SSL encryption, Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) for client and staff access, and secure storage solutions for sensitive client data, ensuring compliance with global data protection best practices.

  • System Audit: While not always mandatory initially, the AOFA may request or mandate an independent security audit or Penetration Testing (Pen Test) report for the VASP’s platform and custody systems, especially during the renewal phase.

Virtual Asset Custody Requirements

 

For VASPs offering crypto custody services, specific security measures are paramount to protect client funds.

  • Cold Storage Policy: A clearly defined policy outlining the percentage of client assets stored in cold storage (offline wallets) versus hot storage (online wallets) is required. Industry best practice recommends holding the majority of funds offline.

  • Key Management: A secure, auditable key management system must be implemented, often involving Multi-Signature (Multi-Sig) technology, requiring multiple authorized personnel to approve transactions.

  • Asset Segregation: Client funds must be strictly segregated from the VASP’s operational and proprietary assets, ensuring client assets are protected in the event of insolvency.

Strategic Advantages and Global Positioning

The Anjouan Crypto License serves as a strategic launchpad, offering significant benefits over other, more expensive or bureaucratically complex jurisdictions.

 

Competitiveness and Market Entry

 

  • Speed to Market: The 6-9 week licensing timeline is a massive advantage, allowing businesses to capitalize on market opportunities far quicker than competitors pursuing licenses in Europe or North America.

  • Cost-Effectiveness: The low initial fees, combined with the zero-tax regime on foreign income, result in a significantly lower Total Cost of Ownership (TCO).

  • Payment Processing and Banking: While securing Tier-1 banking access remains a challenge for any VASP globally, the AOFA license provides the necessary regulatory backing to open accounts with international FinTech-friendly payment providers and banks. The Anjouan license is a crucial element in reducing the perceived risk for international banking partners.

Comparison with Alternative Offshore Jurisdictions

 

The following table highlights the strategic trade-offs between Anjouan and a commonly compared alternative for offshore crypto/iGaming licensing.

FeatureAnjouan (AOFA License)Typical EU/Onshore Jurisdiction (e.g., Malta)
Licensing TimeFast (6–9 weeks)Slow (6–12+ months)
Corporate Tax0% on foreign income5%–35% (variable)
Local PresenceNot Required (No local Directors/Office)Mandatory (Local Directors, Office, Substance)
Initial CostLow ($8k–$16k)High ($50k–$100k+)
Regulatory IntensityModerate (Focus on AML/KYC)High (Prudential, Capital, Consumer Protection)

The Future of Anjouan’s Regulatory Stance

 

Anjouan’s regulatory approach is characterized by agility and adaptability. The AOFA actively seeks to accommodate new technologies, including Web 3.0 protocols, AI-driven platforms, and Provably Fair Gaming Standards in its iGaming sector, a stance that extends directly to its crypto licensing. This flexibility positions Anjouan as a jurisdiction that is welcoming to innovative technologies and prepared to evolve its rules to support digital pioneers.

Deep Dive into Corporate Governance and Reporting

While low on physical presence requirements, the AOFA demands high standards of corporate governance to ensure effective oversight.

 

Corporate Governance Structure

 

The IBC structure, though flexible, must still adhere to basic corporate governance norms.

  • Director Responsibilities: Directors, regardless of their residency, must exercise fiduciary duties, ensuring the company adheres to the AML/KYC Policies and the laws of the jurisdiction where it conducts its core operations.

  • Auditing: While an annual full financial audit is often optional for smaller IBCs, the AOFA requires that financial records be meticulously maintained and readily available for inspection, especially concerning the flow of funds and financial projections outlined in the Business Plan.

Ongoing Compliance and Reporting

 

Maintaining the Crypto License in Anjouan requires continuous compliance and periodic reporting to the AOFA and the relevant financial intelligence unit (FIU) in the Comoros.

  • Annual Renewal: Submission of the annual renewal package must occur at least 60 days before the license expiration date. This package includes updated KYC for all key personnel and a declaration of continued adherence to the AML/CFT framework.

  • Compliance Policy Updates: Any significant change to the VASP’s business model, technology platform, or AML/KYC Procedures must be reported to the AOFA for prior approval.

  • System Integrity Reporting: Licensees must provide regular assurance that their technical systems, particularly the Random Number Generators (RNGs) for linked iGaming operations or the trading algorithms, function reliably and fairly.

Request more information

Final Synthesis: Strategic Value of the Anjouan VASP License

The Anjouan Crypto License offers a unique and highly desirable proposition in the global FinTech landscape: rapid legal certainty combined with minimal corporate overhead. By prioritizing the integrity of its key personnel, maintaining strict internal AML/KYC controls, and securing the services of an experienced Local Registered Agent, a VASP can quickly and affordably establish a legitimate global operational base.

The AOFA authorization is recognized as a strategic enabler, reducing time-to-market while affirming the VASP’s commitment to core anti-money laundering principles, making it an invaluable asset for global expansion in the volatile digital asset sector.

Deep Dive into AML Technology and the Travel Rule

While Anjouan’s regulatory framework is known for its speed and affordability, the Anjouan Offshore Finance Authority (AOFA) and associated financial intelligence units are increasingly mandating the use of advanced technology to meet global standards, particularly concerning the FATF Travel Rule.

 

Implementing the Travel Rule

 

The FATF Travel Rule requires VASPs to transmit certain originator and beneficiary information alongside a virtual asset transfer when the transaction exceeds a specified threshold. For international compliance, implementing a reliable Travel Rule solution is no longer optional, even for offshore jurisdictions like Anjouan.

  • Data Requirements: The VASP must collect and share mandatory data points, including the originator’s name, account number, physical address, and the beneficiary’s name and account number.

  • Technical Adoption: The VASP must integrate a Travel Rule solution provider (TRSP) or protocol (e.g., TRISA, Shyft) into its withdrawal/deposit process. This integration ensures secure, authenticated, and automatic data exchange with counterparty VASPs.

  • De Minimis Thresholds: The VASP’s internal compliance manual must clearly define the application of the Travel Rule based on the transaction value, typically adhering to the international standard equivalent of $1,000 USD for transfers between VASPs.

Blockchain Analytics and On-Chain Monitoring

 

Modern AML compliance in the crypto space relies heavily on blockchain analytics to assess the risk of incoming and outgoing funds.

  • Wallet Screening: The VASP must use specialized software to screen customer deposit addresses for links to known illicit entities, such as darknet markets, sanctioned individuals, terrorist financing, or mixing services.

  • Risk Scoring: Funds received should be subject to a risk scoring model that evaluates the number of hops (transactions) from the source and the reputation of the originating wallet/exchange. High-risk funds should trigger an automatic EDD review and potential blocking.

  • Reporting Unusually Complex Patterns: The system must be configured to flag unusual or fragmented transaction patterns often indicative of structuring (breaking up large transfers to avoid detection) or attempts to evade monitoring.

Prudential Oversight and Consumer Protection Measures

While not as stringent as the capital-heavy requirements of European banks, the AOFA requires VASPs to implement internal controls that ensure financial stability and protect client interests.

 

Internal Risk Management and Solvency

 

Although Anjouan has no fixed minimum capital requirement, the AOFA assesses the VASP’s ability to operate sustainably.

  • Financial Projections: The Business Plan must include conservative financial projections (3-5 years) demonstrating liquidity and solvency based on expected operational costs and potential market volatility.

  • Operational Risk Mitigation: The VASP must detail how it manages operational risks, including system outages, internal fraud, human error, and regulatory penalties. This includes clear lines of responsibility and robust internal controls.

  • Insurance: While not universally mandated, the AOFA strongly recommends that VASPs, especially those offering custody services, secure Professional Indemnity (PI) and Crime Insurance to cover potential losses resulting from negligence or theft.

Client Fund Protection and Transparency

 

Client protection focuses heavily on the structural separation of assets and clear contractual terms.

  • Fiduciary Duty: The VASP operates under a fiduciary duty regarding client assets. The VASP must ensure the complete and verifiable segregation of client funds from all operational capital.

  • Fee Transparency: All terms, conditions, and fee schedules must be disclosed to clients clearly and prominently before any transaction is executed. Hidden or opaque fees are strictly prohibited.

  • Complaints Procedure: The VASP must establish a formal, documented, and responsive client complaints handling procedure. Unresolved complaints should have a clear path for escalation, providing confidence to customers.

Specific Regulatory Considerations for Digital Securities

The versatility of the Anjouan Crypto License extends to the tokenization market, allowing licensed entities to issue or facilitate the trading of tokens that classify as securities, provided international best practices are followed.

 

Security Token Offering (STO) Framework

 

Anjouan is permissive regarding token issuance (ICO/ITO/STO), but requires clear legal differentiation based on the token’s characteristics.

  • Definition of a Security: Tokens that grant investors rights similar to traditional securities (e.g., profit share, voting rights, claims on the company’s assets) are categorized as Security Tokens (STOs) and are subject to stricter internal controls.

  • Investor Protection Disclosures: The VASP must provide comprehensive disclosure documents (similar to a prospectus) that detail the risks, financial model, and legal rights associated with the security token. Issuers must fully comply with the anti-fraud and anti-manipulation provisions of the jurisdictions where the STO is marketed.

  • Geographical Restrictions: The VASP must implement GEO-blocking tools and strict contractual restrictions to ensure that Security Tokens are not marketed or sold in jurisdictions where such activity is prohibited or requires a separate, specific license (e.g., the USA, Canada, or certain EU member states).

The Role of the VASP as an Issuer Facilitator

 

If the Anjouan-licensed VASP facilitates a third-party STO, its due diligence obligations are significantly increased.

  • Issuer Due Diligence: The VASP must perform thorough due diligence on the token issuer, verifying the integrity of the founding team, the legitimacy of the underlying asset, and the legal compliance of the token’s smart contract code.

  • Smart Contract Auditing: All Smart Contracts governing the security token must undergo and pass an independent Smart Contract Audit by a reputable third-party firm before issuance.

Local Engagement and Ongoing Reporting Obligations

The relationship with the Local Registered Agent is the cornerstone of maintaining the Anjouan license. This agent is the VASP’s primary link to the AOFA.

 

The Critical Role of the Local Agent

 

The appointed Local Registered Agent is not merely an administrative contact; they act as the VASP’s official proxy within the jurisdiction.

  • AOFA Liaison: The Agent manages all official communications, regulatory filings, and submissions to the AOFA.

  • Record Keeping: The Agent is legally responsible for maintaining the corporate register, including minutes, resolutions, and the required set of Apostilled corporate documents.

  • Compliance Support: The Agent often provides or oversees the preparation of the mandatory AML/KYC Policy documents, ensuring they comply with the AOFA’s latest standards. Selecting a reputable and experienced Local Registered Agent is the most crucial decision in the licensing process, dictating speed and future compliance ease.

Annual Reporting and Maintenance

 

The VASP must adhere to a clear annual reporting cycle to ensure the continuous validity of the license.

Reporting ElementFrequencySubmission RequirementResponsible Party
License RenewalAnnual (60 days prior to expiry)Updated corporate and personnel KYC, declaration of compliance, renewal fee.VASP, via Local Agent
AML/CFT DeclarationAnnualStatement confirming the effectiveness and testing of the AML/KYC Policies.Compliance Officer/MLRO
Corporate FilingsAnnualPayment of government duties and filing of updated Shareholder/Director Registers.Local Agent
System Integrity ReportAs RequestedThird-party reports on system security and provably fair mechanisms (if applicable).VASP Management

Compliance Officer Profile 

 

The Compliance Officer (CO) / MLRO is the operational backbone of the VASP’s license maintenance.

  • Required Skills: Expertise in international AML standards (FATF, Basel), specific experience with crypto-assets, and strong understanding of the VASP’s technology stack.

  • Certification: While not always a hard AOFA requirement, having internationally recognized certification (e.g., ACAMS) is a significant asset that accelerates the Fit and Proper Test approval.

  • Independence: The CO must have direct access to the board and sufficient authority to enforce policies, including the right to temporarily suspend client relationships or transactions pending an EDD review.

Overcoming Operational Challenges and Global Recognition

Operating with an Anjouan Crypto License involves managing specific challenges inherent to offshore jurisdictions, primarily around global perceptions and banking access.

 

The Reputation Factor

 

Anjouan is sometimes perceived by certain global financial institutions as a “light-touch” jurisdiction. The VASP must proactively mitigate this perception.

  • Transparency and Over-Compliance: The most effective strategy is to implement over-compliance with global AML standards, going beyond the basic local requirement. This includes voluntary adoption of the Travel Rule and utilization of leading Blockchain Analytics providers.

  • Bank De-Risking: Licensed VASPs must be prepared for rigorous scrutiny from potential banking partners. Providing the bank with full transparency regarding the AOFA authorization, the comprehensive AML manual, and detailed proof of asset segregation is essential for securing fiat banking access.

Geographic Limitations and Market Access

 

The Anjouan International Crypto License is designed for international activities, not local commerce.

  • Local Restriction: The VASP is explicitly prohibited from conducting business or providing services to the residents or citizens of Anjouan/Comoros.

  • Restricted Jurisdictions: The VASP must strictly adhere to the AOFA requirement to GEO-block users from sanctioned countries and high-risk jurisdictions as defined by FATF or local policy. A comprehensive list must be part of the operational documentation.

The Strategic Value of the Anjouan VASP Authorization

The Anjouan Crypto License offers a unique and highly desirable proposition in the global FinTech landscape: rapid legal certainty combined with minimal corporate overhead. By prioritizing the integrity of its key personnel, maintaining strict internal AML/KYC controls, and securing the services of an experienced Local Registered Agent, a VASP can quickly and affordably establish a legitimate global operational base.

The AOFA authorization is recognized as a strategic enabler, reducing time-to-market while affirming the VASP’s commitment to core anti-money laundering principles, making it an invaluable asset for global expansion in the volatile digital asset sector.

FAQ

No. The Anjouan VASP license is primarily an offshore International Business Company (IBC) license issued by the Anjouan Offshore Finance Authority (AOFA), focused on company registration and basic AML adherence rather than deep prudential oversight. 

The Anjouan Offshore Finance Authority (AOFA) is the governmental body responsible for issuing the Anjouan VASP license. 

One of the main benefits is speed; the license can often be approved and issued within a few weeks, provided all applicant documentation is complete and accurate. 

The total cost, including government fees and Registered Agent services, is significantly lower than licenses from major onshore jurisdictions, making it highly cost-effective for startups. 

The RA is legally required for all IBCs. The RA conducts the initial due diligence, files the AOFA VASP application process, and ensures the VASP adheres to ongoing basic AML requirements for Anjouan VASP. 

Yes. The Legal status of Anjouan IBC crypto operations grants a major advantage under the island's territorial tax principle: income derived from activities outside of Anjouan is generally exempt from local corporate income tax. 

Typically, no. The IBC structure allows the VASP to operate globally without needing extensive local substance, which contributes to the low Anjouan crypto license cost. 

Yes, this is the biggest challenge. Major international banks often de-risk away from offshore jurisdictions, meaning Anjouan offshore banking for crypto usually requires specialized, crypto-friendly banking solutions. 

No. Unlike major jurisdictions (like Uruguay or Malta), the AOFA generally does not impose significant minimum paid-up Capital requirements for Uruguay crypto license as part of its offshore framework. 

Yes. The Anjouan VASP license is typically structured to cover financial services related to the issuance, offering, or sale of virtual assets, making it suitable for token launches.

Get in touch with our experts